Advice

Why Do Foster Children Lie and Steal?

Foster children sometimes lie or steal, and it rarely means what carers first fear. Here is why it happens, what the law actually says, and how to respond in a way that builds trust rather than shutting it down.
By Richard Norwood
Updated 8 November 2026
Two adults having a supportive conversation

A toy goes missing from someone else’s room. A story about the afternoon doesn’t quite hold together. The first time it happens, it catches you off guard. Here’s what is usually behind it, and what actually helps.

Why Do Children Lie?

Very young children mix up fact and imagination without meaning to deceive anyone. That’s not lying. It’s how their brains are still working things out.

Older children lie for reasons that make sense once you know them.

  • To keep something private
  • To avoid getting into trouble
  • To fit in with friends
  • Because they feel ashamed
  • To protect a relationship they’re afraid of losing
  • Because lying kept them safe before they came to live with you

None of that means the child is being difficult on purpose. A child who has learned that honesty gets punished will protect themselves the only way they know how. It’s a coping habit, not a character flaw, and it usually eases once trust builds.

Why Do Children Steal?

A toddler who takes something isn’t stealing. They don’t yet understand that it belongs to someone else. That understanding usually starts to form from around age four.

Older children steal for different reasons. Survival habits from before. Wanting attention. Poor impulse control. Peer pressure. Sometimes taking something is the only way a child has learned to get what they need.

A common pattern in fostering is a child who hoards or hides food, taking more than they need and stashing it under a bed or in a coat pocket. That isn’t greed. For a child who has gone without, an empty cupboard is frightening in a way it might never have been for you. The food stops being about hunger and starts being about safety.

What This Can Look Like

It’s rarely dramatic. A missing five pound note from your purse. A classmate’s pencil case that turns up in a school bag. A packed lunch that vanishes and a very confident “I already ate it” when it plainly hasn’t been touched.

None of it means you’ve done something wrong. It usually means the child has arrived carrying habits that made sense somewhere else, in a home or a situation where asking for something openly didn’t work.

Is This About Trust?

Often, yes.

A child who has learned that adults can’t be relied on doesn’t always believe that asking will work. Taking something, or lying about it, can feel safer than asking and being told no.

That isn’t an excuse. It’s context. And context changes how you respond.

A teenager who says he lost his bus pass rather than admit he gave it to a friend who didn’t have one is protecting someone, not deceiving you for the sake of it. The instinct to hide the kindness, or the risk, often runs deeper than the instinct to tell you the truth.

What Does the Law Say?

In England, a child cannot be arrested or charged with a crime before their tenth birthday, whatever they’ve done.

Please note: This is general information, not legal advice, correct as at September 2026. The age of criminal responsibility in England has stood at 10 for some years, and while campaigners and some parliamentarians have called for it to rise, there is no confirmed government plan to change it. See the Crown Prosecution Service’s guidance on youth crime at cps.gov.uk for the current position.

Below that age, lying and stealing are things to work through at home, not police matters. Above it, most children never come anywhere near the criminal justice system over a stolen pencil case or a story that didn’t add up. This is a kitchen table problem, almost always, not a courtroom one.

How Should You Respond?

Stay calm. However hard that is in the moment.

Try a soft opening instead of an accusation. Something like: “I can see the pencil case is missing. That’s a shame. Can you tell me what happened?” A calm, curious approach, sometimes called PACE, gives a child room to tell you the truth instead of digging in and defending a lie that’s already out.

A child who expects to be shouted at stops telling you things. A child who is met calmly, more often than not, starts to.

  • Talk it through once things have settled, not mid-argument
  • Be firm about the boundary without shaming the child
  • Reduce the opportunities where you reasonably can, without turning the house into a surveillance operation
  • Praise honesty when it happens, even about something small
  • Note down what happened and any pattern you notice, for your supervising social worker

Small, steady responses matter more than one big conversation. A child tests the same boundary many times before they believe it’s real. That’s ordinary. It isn’t badness, and it settles with time.

When Is It More Than a Phase?

Occasional lying and stealing is common and usually settles as trust grows. A pattern that doesn’t shift, especially alongside aggression or a habit of blaming others, is worth flagging rather than waiting out. Understanding the behaviour underneath it matters more than reacting to the behaviour itself.

Persistent lying and stealing sometimes points to something underneath it: a learned survival habit, unresolved trauma, or, for some children with ADHD, a coping response rather than defiance. None of these are things you diagnose yourself over the dinner table.

Talk to your supervising social worker. Loop in the child’s GP if you’re worried there’s more going on. You are not meant to work out on your own whether this needs extra support, and you shouldn’t try to.

You will not be doing this on your own

You won’t be working this out from a book at your kitchen table, alone, at eleven at night.

Every foster carer with Fostering Hearts has a supervising social worker who supports around six families, not sixty. Training and independence workshops cover things like this before they come up, not only after. And when you do need to write something down for your records, you won’t be guessing at what’s expected.

Wondering whether you could offer a child that kind of steady, unshockable presence?

Book a call back

Or read more about the support you get as a foster carer.

More on feelings and behaviour: sleep · bedwetting · grief and loss · therapeutic play · PACE parenting

Frequently asked questions

Should I punish my foster child for lying or stealing?

Focus on repair and understanding rather than punishment. Explain consequences plainly and calmly. Harsh punishment tends to increase secrecy, not honesty.

What age should I stop expecting this?

Most children understand ownership by around age four, so lying and stealing that continues well past that is worth watching rather than panicking about. Every child is different, and children who’ve had a difficult start often need longer.

Could this be linked to ADHD or another condition?

Sometimes. For a child with ADHD, lying can be a coping response to a task they’re struggling with, rather than defiance. If you’re concerned, talk to your supervising social worker and the child’s GP rather than guessing.

Do I need to write this down?

Yes. Foster carers keep a record of significant incidents for their supervising social worker, in line with normal fostering practice.

Will this affect how long a child stays with me?

No. Lying and stealing are an ordinary part of raising many children who’ve had a hard start. They are not a reason to give up on having a child stay with you. What matters is the support around it, not one incident.

Richard Norwood

Richard Norwood is a director of Fostering Hearts and has worked in fostering for over 25 years.

A good place to start

What’s on your mind?

Your home, your work, your family. Talk it through with someone who understands fostering.

Book a call back

Or call 020 8347 8741
Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm

A small first step

Curious? That’s enough to start.

Ask us the question that’s been on your mind. You don’t have to be ready to apply. Leave your name and number and the team will call you back.

Prefer to talk now? Call 020 8347 8741, Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm.